Mustang Gal, I have the same problem, except I don't wear contacts. I'm just allergic. I've learned that I can only wear it for so long, then I have to wash my eyes and start over. So if I put it on in the a.m., then I have to start over if I'm going out in the evening. All of the eye makeup remover makes my eyes extremely red, but it does go away after about an hour.

I also wish I could find something that doesn't flake.

Daisygirl