Try this...go to MY STUFF at the top of the page. Scroll down and click on WATCH LIST. There should be three headings in there.

Watched Forums Watched Topics Watched Users

Click in one of those and see if you have that particular post under one of these. If you do, click on it and you should get a screen where you can click inside a box and remove it.

Does that help?
_________________________
Queen JJ
www.queenjawjaw.com
All Things Royal - 2010 and Beyond
Humorist for the NABBW