I agree with the treadmill but the reason I do is that it would simply be MY choice of the two. I love to walk. But let me ask you something...is this question as to whether which one to purchase? Or do you aleady have these items? If it's to purchase, wouldn't it be cheaper to go the Curves route? Then nothing left to garage sale later when you grow tired of the thing and discover it will only hold so many pieces of clothing....

Just a thought.

JJ