Yes, my doctor warned me that the surgery might not be a permanent solution. But even if I have to have it redone in a few years, it might be worth it to have 10 to 15 years of relief. I've already suffered with this problem for 25 years...and its been getting worse since my hysterectomy. The Detrol is somewhat helpful, but it has not taken the problem away entirely. I go back to my urologist in August. We'll see what he says then.